Psychological Biases and Investing

I recently finished reading a book about this called Investment Madness, by John R. Nofsinger, an Associate Professor of Finance at Washington State University. It’s very clear, well-organized, well-referenced, and a quick read. The publisher has put the first chapter on-line here. From the introduction:

We are all prone to having psychological preconceptions or biases that make us behave in certain ways. These biases influence how we assimilate the information we come in contact with on a daily basis. They also have an impact on how we utilize that information to make decisions.

Some of the decisions that are influenced by our psychological biases can have a large impact on our personal wealth—or the lack of it. I have written this book to try to show you how your own psychological biases can creep into your investment decisions and sabotage your attempts at building wealth.

In last chapter Nofsinger summarizes the biases in a handy table, which I reproduce here:

Psychological Bias Effect on
Investment Behavior
Overconfidence Trade too much Pay too much
in commissions and taxes
Overconfidence Take too much risk and fail to diversify Susceptible to big losses
Attachment Become emotionally
attached to a security and see it through rose-colored glasses
Susceptible to big losses
Endowment Want to keep
the securities received
Not achieving a match between your investment goals & your investments
Status Quo Hold back on changing your portfolio or allocation and begin starting your 401(k) Failure to adjust asset allocation & begin
contributing to retirement plan
Seeking Pride Sell winners too soon Lower return and higher taxes
Avoiding Regret Hold losers too long Lower return and higher taxes
House Money Take too much risk after winning Susceptible to big losses
Snake Bit Take too little risk after losing Lose chance for higher return in the long term
Get Even Take too much risk trying to break even Susceptible to big even losses
Social Validation Feel that it must be good if others are investing in the security Participate in a price bubble which ultimately causes you to buy high and sell low
Mental Accounting Fail to diversify Not receiving the highest return possible for the level of risk taken
Cognitive Dissonance Ignore information that conflicts with prior beliefs and decisions Reduces your ability to evaluate and monitor your investment choices
Representativeness Think things that seem similar must be alike. So a good company must be a good investment. Purchase
overpriced stocks
Familiarity Think companies that you know seem better & safer Failure to diversify and put too much faith in the company in which you work

Travis Morien (linked in the table) has a good section on investment psychology here. A book I read a few years ago, Why Smart People Make Big Money Mistakes, is also worthwhile. Cornell U. Psychology Professor Thomas Gilovich is a coauthor, and also wrote How We Know What Isn’t So, which I also enjoyed.



Filed under economics, psychology

2 responses to “Psychological Biases and Investing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s