Governments are poor stewards of forests

From New Scientist:

In the first study of its kind, Chhatre and Arun Agrawal of the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor compared forest ownership with data on carbon sequestration, which is estimated from the size and number of trees in a forest. Hectare-for-hectare, they found that tropical forest under local management stored more carbon than government-owned forests. There are exceptions, says Chhatre, “but our findings show that we can increase carbon sequestration simply by transferring ownership of forests from governments to communities”.

The New Scientist article is gated, and I got the above quote from Tyler Cowen at Marginal Revolution. For more, see his post: The economics of local forest management (or another lesson in Elinor Ostrom).

In Reason magazine, Ronald Bailey writes:

Authors Ashwini Chhatre, a geographer at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and Arun Agrawal, a political scientist specializing in environmental policy at the University of Michigan, offer evidence that governments have a habit of licensing destructive logging and that they often fail to prevent resource rustling. In contrast, Chhatre and Agrawal found, forests owned by local communities are managed for the long term and store lots of carbon dioxide.

As Chhatre told New Scientist, “Our findings show that we can increase carbon sequestration simply by transferring ownership of forests from governments to communities.” Chhatre and Agrawal further suggest that locals are better at managing common pastures, coastal fisheries, and water supplies.

Read the whole article: Who owns the forests?.

movie: Collateral

I saw this movie tonight and enjoyed it. It’s worthy of a blog entry, but perhaps not worthy of being on my del.icio.us video links page. Anyway, this is an action movie with good dialogue and something to think about. I identified with Max, played by Jamie Foxx, who was basically a perfectionist, that is, someone who puts off choices (and his life ambitions) for fear of making a mistake. As David Byrne sings in “Back in the Box

If I don’t make no decisions, then I won’t make no mistakes. But through all those tiny holes, well the light’s still getting in! I’m going back in the box…Back in the box again

Good point, though the double negatives make me cringe.

Hmm. Apparently the director of this movie, Michael Mann, also produced the ’80s television show Miami Vice, and a movie will come out this year. Now I wonder if Crockett and Tubbs are made to be the clear-cut (but not clean cut) good guys in enforcing drug prohibition – which, to say the least, is bad policy, according to both wonks and those in law enforcement. I was nine-years old when I saw it last. I mean, did the dynamic duo get their cool car from asset forfeiture? Well, at least according to at least one article, “Vice did not portray federal law enforcement agents as heroes. Instead, they often were portrayed as crooks at worst and bumblers at best.”

David Byrne at Chautauqua

That was last week. What a fine concert – bought a ticket, and then sold it soon after to sit outside with friends who had brought wine, cheese, and other delicacies. I don’t listen to David Byrne as much as I used to, as my musical tastes have moved on. I almost let that story get in the way of my seeing the concert, and that would have been unwise.

Today is my dad’s birthday. Happy birthday, Dad!